Sign In
New York Business Times Logo
  • Home
  • Business
  • Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Finance
  • Sports
Reading: Betting on the presidential elections has begun
Share
newyorkbusinesstimes.comnewyorkbusinesstimes.com
Aa
  • Business
  • Finance
  • Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
Search
  • Business
  • Finance
  • Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
© 2022 Foxiz News Network. Ruby Design Company. All Rights Reserved.
Home » Betting on the presidential elections has begun
Business

Betting on the presidential elections has begun

Dakota Johnson
Last updated: 2023/11/11 at 3:49 AM
Dakota Johnson
Share
Betting on the presidential elections has begun
SHARE

[ad_1]

Contents
Markets versus pollsWhich question?The state of affairs

Financial journalists love Wall Street aphorisms. I use them whenever I can.

“Don’t fight the Fed” has come in handy this year. “The stock market is climbing a wall of worry” is useful when investors are worried.

Here’s one that I’ve never been able to put into an article – not yet, anyway: “It’s an old axiom in the Financial District that Wall Street bets are ‘never wrong’.”

But almost a century ago, on September 28, 1924, one of my anonymous predecessors at The New York Times (bylines were unusual then) used it. This sacred saying could be used again today, barring a formidable problem. It refers to the election betting that took place on Wall Street, which was common at the time – and covered extensively in The Times and other major newspapers, as a major source of information on national, state and local political contests.

Today, outright betting on elections, beyond indirect and extensive financial hedges on the policy implications of election results, is no longer a core part of American finance.

However, legal battles are underway to change that. And in the meantime, three prediction markets – PredictIt, Kalshi and the Iowa Electronic Markets – remain active and generating compelling insights. With them it is possible to make bets on who will win the 2024 presidential elections and on a large number of other resulting matters.

Markets versus polls

I have been using prediction markets for years, especially during election season, just as my predecessors probably used the election betting markets on Wall Street – not to place bets, but to obtain information.

I am not dependent on these markets, and do not believe in the idea that they are superior to other ways of obtaining information – or that they have the ability to reliably predict the future or change the world.

Yet they are enlightening. Some research has found that prediction markets compare favorably with polls, especially if you are weeks or months away from the vote. And when an issue or election is important, you can never have enough data.

For example, right now.

The latest New York Times/Siena College poll shows President Biden trailing former President Donald J. Trump in five of six swing states ahead of the 2024 election. However, both PredictIt and the Iowa market indicate that most people placing bets on those sites believe Mr. Biden will ultimately win.

Which question?

John Aristotle Phillips, who runs the PredictIt market on behalf of the Victoria University of Wellington, a New Zealand institution, said in an interview that there were often large differences between the findings of the polls and the prediction markets. That’s completely normal, he said. “Opinion polls and prediction markets ask different questions.”

A poll asks who you would currently prefer as a candidate. But a functioning market that charges real money for a transaction demands something else, he said, “not who you are.” want to to win, but who you think will win.”

As a sports fan, I understand the difference. If you asked me what baseball team I… popular to win, I would always pick the Mets. But for decades, they’ve mostly disappointed me. So if I had to put down money, I would never bet on them.

What am I really thinking? It depends what question you ask.

The state of affairs

Kalshi, PredictIt, and the Iowa market operate legally, but operate under specific restrictions.

A common problem is that “no state allows gambling on political events and, if it were allowed, it would be on a state-by-state basis,” said Cait DeBaun, vice president of the American Gaming Association, which represents the gambling industry. . If you’re watching a game on television in most major markets, you can’t avoid the temptation to bet on sports, but you won’t see ads for betting on politics. They are not allowed.

But both PredictIt and the Iowa market openly offer political betting under academic exemptions granted by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission.

The Iowa market, which started in 1988, is the most purely academic of the three. It is completely dedicated to research and education, but is open to anyone who wants to take a chance.

PredictIt also operates under an academic exemption, but has had to fight to keep it. The CFTC revoked its permission in August 2022 and ordered the site closed, saying it had strayed from its academic mission. But PredictIt has won a court order allowing the company to continue operating, and it is suing the CFTC, seeking permanent authority to govern its market.

There are currently 19 contracts in progress, but Mr Phillips said he expected to offer “hundreds” soon. “We’re not going anywhere,” he said. “We remain active.”

Kalshi, the largest of the three sites, currently has the most restrictions when it comes to betting on politics. As a commercial derivatives market, it can accept transactions worth tens of millions of dollars.

It already runs prediction markets on inflation, unemployment, oil prices, Federal Reserve policy, government shutdowns, the temperature in Austin, which will win an Oscar, and President Biden’s approval rating. The consensus forecasts are often accurate and extremely useful.

But what Kalshi has not been able to do is run a market by predicting which political party will control Congress. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission rejected it, saying it would violate the election contract ban implied by the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010. That’s why Kalshi sued the CFTC this month.

In an interview, Tarek Mansour, founder of Kalshi, said he would eventually like to start markets for presidential elections and a range of other contests. “Election betting is as old as the United States,” he said, adding that if that betting doesn’t happen through a careful marketplace like his, it will happen somewhere else anyway.

He already pointed out that sophisticated and well-financed investors can hedge against the risks of election results through tailor-made derivative contracts entered into by investment banks. “Why should we limit these transactions to the very wealthy?” he asked. “We want to make this type of hedging available to the average investor.”

I said I would call these “trades” bets.

He said, “I don’t disagree with that.”

Betting on American elections takes place abroad. Betfair in Britain has a robust market. And unregulated offshore betting runs on Polymarket, which uses cryptocurrency and was fined $1.4 million by the CFTC for violating its rules. Then there’s FTX, the failed cryptocurrency exchange run by Sam Bankman-Fried, who was convicted this month of seven counts of fraud and conspiracy. It operated an unregulated, offshore prediction market during the 2020 election cycle.

“It doesn’t make sense for me to take these markets offshore,” Mr. Mansour said.

I leave these legal issues for the courts and regulatory authorities to decide.

But like my journalistic predecessors, I welcome the wealth of data that election betting provides. I hope that the entrepreneurs who run prediction markets will keep the information flowing so that we can truly test the truth of the old adage, “Wall Street betting odds are never wrong.”

Dakota Johnson 11 November 2023 11 November 2023
Share This Article
Twitter Email Copy Link Print
By Dakota Johnson
Dakota Johnson is a highly accomplished business expert known for her profound understanding of the corporate world and the intricacies of entrepreneurship. She embarked on her journey with New York Business Times in 2017 as a business correspondent and has since carved out a distinguished career in the field.
Previous Article Unity shares fall as the company posts a revenue loss and skips guidance Unity shares fall as the company posts a revenue loss and skips guidance
Next Article Apple will pay  million toward the DOJ’s discrimination settlement Apple will pay $25 million toward the DOJ’s discrimination settlement
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Oponion

Award-winning British journalist and children’s writer Dawn-Maria France has ventured into animation as a creator and scriptwriter! BY Torie Boyd

Award-winning British journalist and children’s writer Dawn-Maria France has ventured into animation as a creator and scriptwriter! BY Torie Boyd

Dawn-Maria France is an award-winning British journalist and Yorkshire Women's…

21 February 2025

Fake news sites with Russian ties flood the US

In a dwindling field of journalism…

29 January 2025

US added 275,000 jobs in February as growth remains strong: Live updates

If the economy is slowing down,…

29 January 2025

Bitcoin made a great comeback and touched a record high

Bitcoin hit a record high of…

29 January 2025

Britain will cut taxes again as elections approach

Amid weak economic growth prospects, the…

29 January 2025

Your inhalers and EpiPens aren’t very healthy for the environment

A single-use insulin pen changed Brian…

29 January 2025

An upbeat FTC boosts Biden’s efforts to address inflation

An independent federal agency has become…

29 January 2025

Disney to step back from India in mega-deal with Reliance Industries

Walt Disney Co. on Wednesday announced…

29 January 2025

Developers received support for affordable housing. Then the neighborhood came to know.

When developers planned to build 60…

29 January 2025

You Might Also Like

Award-winning British journalist and children’s writer Dawn-Maria France has ventured into animation as a creator and scriptwriter! BY Torie Boyd
Business

Award-winning British journalist and children’s writer Dawn-Maria France has ventured into animation as a creator and scriptwriter! BY Torie Boyd

Dawn-Maria France is an award-winning British journalist and Yorkshire Women's Life Magazine editor-in-chief. Originally from Harrogate, she is also a…

2 Min Read
Fake news sites with Russian ties flood the US
Business

Fake news sites with Russian ties flood the US

In a dwindling field of journalism in the US, a handful of websites have emerged in recent weeks with names…

10 Min Read
US added 275,000 jobs in February as growth remains strong: Live updates
Business

US added 275,000 jobs in February as growth remains strong: Live updates

If the economy is slowing down, no one told the labor market.The Labor Department reported Friday that employers added 275,000…

6 Min Read
Bitcoin made a great comeback and touched a record high
Business

Bitcoin made a great comeback and touched a record high

Bitcoin hit a record high of more than $69,000 on Tuesday, marking a remarkable comeback for the volatile cryptocurrency after…

7 Min Read
New York Business Times Logo

News

  • Sponsored & Guest Post
  • Remove News

CATEGORY

  • Business
  • Finance
  • Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Sports

INFORMATION

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions

Social Media

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • X
  • Linkedin

© New York Business Times. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?